- Dangerous precedent, says Dhankhar as Oppn walk out during PM’s speech
New Delhi, July 03 (PTI): Prime Minister Narendra Modi Wednesday took the Congress to the cleaners over making the 2024 general elections about the protection of the Constitution, saying Indians voted on the plank only once when they threw out the Indira Gandhi government in 1977 after the Emergency.
Speaking in Rajya Sabha, he gave an account of the situation in strife-torn Manipur, promised action in the NEET paper leak case, and listed out achievements of his past two terms and priorities for the third.
A day after his spirited response to the debate in Lok Sabha on a motion to thank President Droupadi Murmu for her address to the joint sitting of Parliament, Modi launched an all-out attack on the Congress, saying it speaks with a forked tongue, opposing celebration of the Constitution Day while doing the “drama” of protecting the Constitution during polls.
This infuriated INDIA bloc parties, who shouted slogans and calling Modi a “liar”. Leader of the Opposition in Rajya Sabha Mallikarjun Kharge wanted to intervene but was not allowed, leading to the opposition MPs trying to drown out Modi’s speech by raising slogans. Later they staged a walkout.
Undeterred, Modi continued his speech and said the Congress was running away as it does not have the courage to hear the truth. Chairman Jagdeep Dhankhar also condemned the walkout, calling it an insult to the Constitution.
In his nearly two-hour speech, Modi listed out his previous government’s achievements: from raising MSP for crops to giving the poor access to the banking system and loans, and fuelling India’s rise to become the fifth largest economy.
With development and self-reliance as pivot, Modi said, India will “definitely” become the third largest economy in the world in his third term.
The prime minister, who started his first term in May 2014, said people have given mandate to the BJP-led NDA to make India a developed nation. He said the Opposition is “unable to digest” the mandate given by 140 crore people to the NDA. “I understand your pain,” he said.
“Their all efforts failed yesterday. Today they did not have courage to fight that and therefore they left the field. I am bound by my duty. I am not here to score in a debate. I am servant of the country. I am here to give a detailed account of our work and it is my duty,” he said as the Opposition walked out of the House.
Modi also took a jibe at the opposition for terming the current NDA dispensation “one-third government”, asking “what could be a greater truth than this?”
“It has been 10 years (of the BJP-led NDA government) and there are 20 more (years) to go. One-third in done, two-third is left,” he said.
Referring to the Congress party’s repeated claim during elections that BJP would change the Constitution, Modi said, “I want to remind them. Will you continue this fake narrative? Have you forgotten the 1977 elections when newspapers and radio were shut. There was no freedom of speech. People then voted on one issue — re-establishing the Constitution and protection of Constitution.”
There has not been more painful election than the one held in 1977 in the world, he said.
“The 1977 polls clearly shows how (the urge of) saving the Constitution was alive in the hearts of people. Are you misleading the people (now)? At that time, people threw (Indira Gandhi) out of power,” he said.
He said that for his party, the Constitution is not just a compilation of articles but its spirit and words are very important too. The Constitution is like a lighthouse which shows his government direction, Modi said.
He also attacked Congress’ allies, saying they too were the victims of the excesses committed during the Emergency, but have now joined hands for political opportunism.
On the Manipur situation, Modi said violence in the state is continuously declining and educational institutions have reponed and businesses are operational in most part of the state.
“The government is making continuous efforts to bring normalcy in Manipur,” he said, and informed over 11,000 FIRs have been filed in connection with violence in the state and more than 500 people have been arrested.
He stressed the Centre and state were talking to everyone there for opening the door to peace.
Modi also spoke on the alleged irregularities in the conduct of competitive exams, and asserted tough action will be taken against those involved in paper leaks.
“We wanted there should be no politics on a sensitive issue like paper leak, but the opposition is used to it. I assure the youth of India that action is being taken to ensure that those who play with the future of youths are handed down strict punishment,” he said.
The prime minister vowed further crackdown on corruption and blackmoney, saying the government has given “full freedom” to probe agencies for taking strongest action against the corrupt and no one will be spared.
He also took potshot at the Congress party for levelling serious allegations with evidence against the AAP and then forming an alliance with it to fight the Lok Sabha polls.
“I want to state without hesitation and also tell the people op the country that I have given full freedom to agencies to take the strongest action against the corrupt and corruption. The government will not interfere anywhere,” the prime minister said.
“Yes they (probe agencies) should work honestly. No person embroiled in corruption will be able to escape the law. This is Modi’s guarantee,” the PM said.
Rejecting the charge that the government is misusing probe agencies, Modi cited statements of opposition leaders, like the late Mulayam Singh Yadav who had accused the UPA government of using ED and CBI against them.
“The AAP commits liquor scam, AAP commits corruption, AAP commits scam in building classrooms for children, AAP even commits water scam… the Congress complains against the AAP, the Congress drags AAP to court and if action is taken then they abuse Modi,” he said.
He also accused the opposition of selective outrage on atrocities against women, saying none of them said a word on public beating of a woman in West Bengal.
Meanwhile, Rajya Sabha Chairman Jagdeep Dhankhar said the Opposition has set a “dangerous precedent antithetical to democratic values” by walking out during Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s reply during discussion on the motion of thanks to President’s address.
In his concluding remarks of the 264th session of Rajya Sabha before adjourning the House sine die, Dhankhar also termed the instance of Leader of Opposition Mallikarjun Kharge walking into the well of the House during the session “a disgrace to parliamentary conduct and proprietary”.
Summing up the proceedings of the session, the chairman said while there was active participation from both the treasury as well as opposition benches, he was constrained to make some observations that “weighed heavily on my mind over the disruptions that marred the proceedings”.
“Witnessing seasoned members conduct themselves irresponsibly was particularly disheartening. I wish to reiterate that disruption not only impedes the transaction of the listed business but also erodes the prestige of this esteemed institution,” he asserted.
Pointing out the instance of Kharge entering the Well of the Rajya Sabha on Friday, Dhankhar said, “It was extremely painful to notice that even the Leader of the Opposition walked into the Well of the House and that was a disgrace to parliamentary conduct and proprietary.”
He asked the members of the House to “exemplify their conduct so that this becomes a temple for deliberations, discussion, dialogue and debate”.
“Their walkout today was extremely painful. It was a historic occasion. The government was in its third term with the prime minister heading it continually after six decades. They walked away from their constitutional ordainment and that has set a dangerous precedent antithetical to democratic values,” Dhankhar said.
The 264th session of the Upper House began with President Droupadi Murmu’s address to both houses of Parliament, which the chairman described as “an important tradition that set the tone and outlined the government’s agenda”.
The House also witnessed Modi introducing his new council of ministers after he was sworn-in as the prime minister for the third consecutive term.
“The Motion of Thanks to the President’s address witnessed lively participation by 76 members for over 21 hours. The House also heard maiden speeches by 19 newly-elected members,” Dhankhar said.
The Rajya Sabha chairman said while the prime minister gave a “spirited address while participating in the debate”, the House lost 43 minutes due to forced adjournments but the shortfall was “made up by continuing discussion during lunch break and sitting beyond the scheduled time”.
“Due to extended sitting, the total duration of business was finally extended by three hours beyond the scheduled time and, therefore, we scored more than 100 per cent in our productivity,” he added.
